If you feel like you didn't get your money's worth, by all means get another. If I placed a lot on money down for new guitar I to would expect a minty finish.
However if I was going to use it for gigs I wouldn't mind as much. For me it depends on the use.
So I have sent it back and a new one is coming. They where willing to refund me some money but I wanted and expected perfection for $2500 (that's what they cost in Australia).